What’s the Difference Between A E Collar VS Shock Collar?

Difference Between A E Collar VS Shock Collar

The collar is a restraint that wraps around the neck and has a strap across the chest. It can be used to control, lead, or guide an animal and train it to stop doing certain things.

In this blog post, we will cover two different types of collars: shock collars vs. e-collars. 

The dog proximity collar and what human food can i feed my diabetic dog are our most visited resources that you might also like to read.

Shock Collar

The shock collar uses electricity from batteries or from being plugged into an electric outlet to create a painful sensation on the dog’s neck when they bark excessively or do something other than what their owners want them too.

This form of punishment is not recommended by veterinarians because there have been studies that show how stress can cause long term health problems in dogs, such as heart issues,

A shock collar cannot only put the dog in pain, but it may lead to aggression and even cause them to injure or kill another animal.


The e-collar delivers a slight vibration, nick, or beep when activated by the owner.  It can also provide an automatic signal when outside of the boundary.

The e-collar is usually worn on the midline of the neck, which can irritate some dogs. However, this form of training has been around for decades, and it is used by the military, police forces, farmers, hunters, and professional dog trainers. In addition, this method does not use pain, so there are no health concerns.

Understanding Shock Collars and E-Collars

At AnimalWised, we are no fans of using pain to train an animal. This does not mean that the e-collar is the perfect training tool for every dog or cat. However, it can be effective when used correctly, and it has transformed many dogs’ lives by removing stress and anxiety from their everyday life.

If you decide to use this type of collar, make sure:

It is used correctly (more on that later). The pet understands why they are receiving a correction. You know how to set up and maintain the system Quality collars need to be purchased.

Do your research before you start using such a device on your pet because there should be a positive reinforcement in odd cases like these.

Both types of collars have their own set of pros and cons. The shock collar can cause irreparable damage to your pet’s health, but the e-collar is not as cruel.

Use it correctly if you are considering using one, or ask your veterinarian for advice on training your pet without inflicting harm or pain to them.

The Ins and Outs of Shock Collars and E Collar for Dogs

We are going to cover some of the most pressing questions about shock collars. This way, you can make an informed decision if these types of devices would benefit your pet.

1. Are shock collars safe?

This depends on who you ask. If you ask your veterinarian, they will probably tell you that there are no long-term health effects of using one.

However, suppose you search online for information about shock collars. In that case, the results will be conflicting because not all veterinary professionals agree that shock collars are harmless for dogs’ physical and mental well-being.

There is not much research done on animals using these devices, but studies have shown how stress can cause long-term damage to their health, such as heart issues.

If you feel like this type of training would help your dog or cat become more obedient, think again before deciding to use it.

2. Is it humane to use an e-collar on a dog?

No. The electronic collar might be effective in training your pet, but using one is detrimental to their physical and mental health.

You can start teaching your pet the necessary commands without inflicting pain simply by using positive reinforcement methods such as treats and praise. If you think these collars are cruel, they genuinely are not suitable for training purposes.

3. Is there such a thing as too much pressure when it comes to shock collars?

Yes, there is. If you use a shock collar and your pet reacts immediately, it probably means that the pressure was too much or your timing was off.

This can be psychologically harmful to them and physically if their neck gets injured from jerking around so much.

4. How do you become certified in training with an e-collar?

The e-collar is an exceptional tool that has transformed many dogs’ lives; however, this type of device should only be used under certain circumstances.

First of all, you should discuss with your vet if an e-collar is the right choice for your pet.

If they favor this type of collar, it is best to go with one with various levels of stimulation to introduce them to the feeling gradually.

The trainer should be certified before using a device because shock collars have been known to cause physical and psychological damage to dogs.

They also need a lot of training and guidance from someone who understands how these devices work.

It would be too difficult to teach a dog how to use one properly on its own. Make sure whoever trains your pet knows what they are doing because this could potentially harm your four-legged friend.

Why Exactly Do People Use E Collars For Dogs?

E-collars are also known as remote trainers, and they deliver a static electric pulse or vibrate to your pet’s neck.

When you cannot be with your dog, and they go off their leash, this device can be helpful because it can help stop them before they get too far away from you.

Best Practices for Dogs with E- Collar

1. Timing is everything when it comes to using the e-collar on your pet.

Please do not put the collar on your dog then walk away expecting them to know what to do. You have to be able to read their behavior and communicate with them. If you are not confident in training them to use a shock collar, do not attempt it.

This device is made to help improve your pet’s behavior, but it will work better if you communicate with them properly.

2. Make sure that the e-collar fits appropriately. If it is too loose or too tight, this could impair functionality and potentially hurt your dog.

The best way to test if it fits nicely is by placing it around your wrist and pressing the button. If you feel a shock, take it off and try again with another size or model until you find one that works for them.

3. If this is your first time using an e-collar on your dog, do not use a high level of shock.

It is best to start with a low setting and work your way up while monitoring their behavior.

Do not set the device on a higher level if they are not reacting to the lower settings.

4. If your dog becomes afraid or uncomfortable when using the e-collar, then this means it is probably too strong for them.

Would you please switch to a lower setting or reduce the coverage area so they can feel more comfortable when wearing the collar?

5. Your dog needs to be properly conditioned before using an e-collar because it will not work if they are afraid of it.

Reasons Many People Gravitate to E-Collars

  • 1. E-collars are a great way to train a dog without inflicting too much harm on them.
  • 2. This device can be a lifesaver for some owners because it allows them to control their pets from a distance without losing sight of them.
  • 3. They come in handy if you plan on taking your dog camping or to the park.
  • 4. They assist in preventing your dog from harming other people or animals while away from you.
  • 5. This device is a good option for owners who struggle to get their pets to listen and follow commands.
  • 6. It can help rehabilitate an aggressive dog that tends to bite other animals or people around them.