No Pull Harness vs Regular Harness Which One is Better?

No Pull Harness vs Regular Harness

It’s no secret that the internet is full of conflicting opinions on how to take care of our pets. The debate between a regular harness and a No Pull Harness has been going on for years, and some experts say it doesn’t make any difference, but we think you should know why we prefer the latter.

If you are a pet parent, you know the struggle of trying to walk your dog without having them pull on its leash. The No Pull Harness is an excellent option for those who want to have more control over their dogs when walking them outside.

It does not allow for pulling and can be adjusted in multiple ways according to the dog’s body shape.

This harness allows for greater freedom of movement without the restriction that regular harnesses might offer.

You might also like our recent reviews on the best shock collar for small dogs and camping fences available on the separate page for your consideration.

What is the difference between a no-pull harness and a regular harness?

The no-pull harness is designed with a leash attachment ring located on the center of the chest, rather than on the back, so that when a dog pulls while on a walk, it will be turned slightly to discourage pulling.

A regular harness is designed with the leash attachment ring located at the dog’s back so that there is some degree of resistance when they move around and pulls.

What is the purpose of using a no-pull harness?

The purpose is to discourage your dog from pulling on their leash during walks so they will walk by your side and not be at risk for injury to their trachea or clavicle. This can also help keep you in better control of your dog while walking them.

Step in harness vs regular harness

Some harnesses are designed so that you step into them, similar to how you would put on a jacket or coat, while others have loops through which you place each leg.

The adjustable nature of the no-pull design allows for proper fitting and comfort for your dog. For example, the straps should not be too tight around their legs or too loose so they can slip out of the harness.

If the leash attachment ring is on top of the dog’s back, it will be difficult to get a proper fit and put it on properly because you will need to attach the leash to their neck or head area rather than the center of their chest area.

A front-attachment harness such as the no-pull also allows for a better fit and more control because you can use a shorter leash, which is ideal.

Front harness vs Back harness

Some harnesses have a leash attachment ring in the front of the dog, which will offer more control when they want to pull ahead.

Although, ideally, you would want both your hands on their leash for better control and to make sure they don’t pull away from you or dart into traffic or other unsafe areas.

A back-attachment harness will allow dogs to pull more because there is less control and can even injure their trachea. The back-attachment leash ring is also difficult to adjust properly, which may make it uncomfortable for your dog or cause chafing on long walks.

The harness material should be comfortable for your pet as well as durable enough to handle.

Why Are Conventional Harnesses So Uncomfortable for Dogs?

Conventional harnesses tend to be uncomfortable and cumbersome for dogs. This is because dog’s bodies are so different from ours. After all, we walk upright, and they have four legs.

When a dog pulls on the conventional harness, it will put pressure behind its front legs, so it doesn’t work too well as a restraint.

It also puts pressure around their necks and can cause chafing and discomfort when wearing for a prolonged period of time.

A no-pull harness is designed in such a way that it can be adjusted to fit each dog uniquely, so they are comfortable while they walk by your side, not pulled around by their necks.

Mesh Dog Harnesses

Mesh harnesses can also be very uncomfortable for dogs to wear due to the mesh material rubbing against their body.

Harnesses that are not made with a soft material on the contact points where they will touch your dog’s skin are not recommended because they can cause chafing, discomfort, or even skin irritation or infections.

Step-in Dog Harnesses

Most step-in harnesses are designed very similarly to the no-pull harness, although they might not have a leash attachment ring on top of their chest.

You slip your dog’s body through the opening, adjust it accordingly and attach the leash to their back for better control.

The advantage of this type of harness is there’s no need to pull over your dog’s head.

However, you might still have trouble with a properly fitted harness if it is too big or too small and can lead to other problems such as discomfort, chafing, and even choking.

Be sure to get one that has adjustable straps so it will fit your dog’s body well and won’t go over their faces.

2 Ring Velvet Harnesses

This type of harness is very similar to step-in but has two rings on the front instead of one.

It has an adjustable neck strap and features two attachment points for your leash ends, located on either side of your dog’s body.

On top of that, there is a circular ring right above their back which is also designed for a leash attachment.

This type of harness is typically made from velvet, nylon, or soft cotton materials and has padded chest straps that go across their chest, which can help relieve the pressure from pulling.

Fabric Dog Harness with Front and Back Lead Rings

Many dog owners prefer a fabric harness because it is typically made from soft and comfortable material.

The front ring on a fabric harness rests against the chest area, while the attachment ring for your leash is located on top of its back.

There are many different types of materials used to make these types of harnesses and different styles.

For example, some of them may have a front and back ring for better control of your dog while they walk next to you, while others might only feature one ring on top of their back.

However, keep in mind that most fabric harnesses are not designed properly, leading to discomfort and even chafing or skin irritation.


What is no pull dog harnesses good for?

No-pull harnesses are great training tools to help you control your dog while walking.

It is recommended that you use a leash that attaches on top of their back to give you more control over them in case they try to pull.

Allowing your dog to walk by your side instead of pulling can result in many health benefits, especially for bigger breeds.

For example, walking your dog by your side instead of pulling can help reduce their risk for neck/back injuries which are common among large dogs who pull on the conventional harness. It will also improve the way they breathe because it keeps their chest and lungs free from pressure.

No-pull harnesses can be very helpful while training your dog to stop pulling. Still, it would be best to always use positive reinforcement training to motivate and encourage good behavior.

Are No-Pull Harnesses Really More Comfortable for Your Dog?

No-pull harnesses are designed to be more comfortable for your dog compared to conventional dog harnesses that put pressure on their neck and chest area.

The type of material used in no-pull harnesses is typically softer than other types, which makes it easier for them to wear without the risk of chafing or skin irritation.

Does the Material of a Harness Matter?

The material used to make no-pull harnesses is not very important.

There are many different materials available, but most of them are typically soft and comfortable without the risk of irritating your pet’s skin or causing discomfort.

However, it is still important that you choose one that fits your dog properly so they can move their legs easily. Poor material dog harnesses may cause hair loss in dogs.

How Effective is a No-Pull Harness?

No-pull harnesses are great training tools that can help you control your dog’s pulling behavior.

It is recommended that you use a leash that attaches directly to their back so it will be easier for you to guide them in the right direction.

Allowing your dog to walk by your side instead of pulling can significantly reduce their risk of injury, especially for large breeds.

Plus, it can help improve their breathing by using their chest and lungs freely without any pressure.

No-pull harnesses are also very useful during training because they give you more control over your dog, making it easier for you to motivate good behavior.

Related Posts